I wouldn't just put the blame on the party, it all depends on what gear Gearless has and what the expectation of the group is. If he's all in quest greens and blues, and doesn't have any crafted pieces, enchants, or gems, then I don't think he should be jumping into heroics like that and expecting to be pulling his weight. Expecting to pull your weight in a heroic as a new 80 with everyone else in Uld/Naxx gear is not reasonable, even as a DPS. Also, most raid people who are doing heroics are doing so to farm badges, and they want to get through it as quickly as possible.
You should either find a group that's willing to run heroics more casually for you to gear you up, or you should max out your character doing normal mode dungeons, getting best in slot crafted items, buying purples on the AH, etc. It shouldn't be too hard to find a guild willing to help you out. My guild runs casual raids on weekends for alts and new raiders, maybe you can find a guild who does something similar and join them.
Theorycrafting isn't just for max gear... you can use plenty of the same techniques to gauge what's reasonable DPS for you given your gear. EJ also can tell you what good talent specs are to optimize your DPS, what stats are most important, and what kind of cast rotations you should be using.
You can also use a tool called Rawr to estimate what your optimal DPS should be. You plug your gear in, select the buffs you have, and set up stats for your target, and it will tell you roughly what DPS you should be doing, and how you can upgrade your gear as well.
"What this all boils down to is this... unless you are a sponsored guild that is getting paid to be the best, noone has the right to exclude someone else from end game content based on arbitrary criteria. After all, the person in question was good enought to be invited into 'your' guild in the first place...."
Actually, a guild leader has any right to exclude you from end game content for any reason they want. They are the leader, it's their (not 'their') guild. Guilds are not a democracy.
Nobody can exclude you from end game content. They can just ask that you do end game content with someone else. If you don't like it, go find a guild with a leader who seems reasonable to you.
BlizzCon 2009: Cataclysm - Zones video
Aug 21st 2009 8:09PM (WoW)Cataclysm races leaked
Aug 10th 2009 2:36PM (WoW)Drama Mamas: It's not you - it's them
Aug 7th 2009 2:40PM (WoW)I wouldn't just put the blame on the party, it all depends on what gear Gearless has and what the expectation of the group is. If he's all in quest greens and blues, and doesn't have any crafted pieces, enchants, or gems, then I don't think he should be jumping into heroics like that and expecting to be pulling his weight. Expecting to pull your weight in a heroic as a new 80 with everyone else in Uld/Naxx gear is not reasonable, even as a DPS. Also, most raid people who are doing heroics are doing so to farm badges, and they want to get through it as quickly as possible.
You should either find a group that's willing to run heroics more casually for you to gear you up, or you should max out your character doing normal mode dungeons, getting best in slot crafted items, buying purples on the AH, etc. It shouldn't be too hard to find a guild willing to help you out. My guild runs casual raids on weekends for alts and new raiders, maybe you can find a guild who does something similar and join them.
AutoStitch raises the bar on iPhone panoramas
Jun 12th 2009 11:25PM (TUAW.com)The Queue: Locke
May 7th 2009 8:27PM (WoW)You can also use a tool called Rawr to estimate what your optimal DPS should be. You plug your gear in, select the buffs you have, and set up stats for your target, and it will tell you roughly what DPS you should be doing, and how you can upgrade your gear as well.
The Queue: Locke
May 7th 2009 8:20PM (WoW)"What this all boils down to is this... unless you are a sponsored guild that is getting paid to be the best, noone has the right to exclude someone else from end game content based on arbitrary criteria. After all, the person in question was good enought to be invited into 'your' guild in the first place...."
Actually, a guild leader has any right to exclude you from end game content for any reason they want. They are the leader, it's their (not 'their') guild. Guilds are not a democracy.
Nobody can exclude you from end game content. They can just ask that you do end game content with someone else. If you don't like it, go find a guild with a leader who seems reasonable to you.
Noblegarden: Sexy or Sexist?
May 1st 2009 2:39PM (WoW)Do you know how hard it is to find a female tauren?!?!
Breakfast Topic: What's the best pun name you've ever seen?
Apr 19th 2009 7:43PM (WoW)Tho I do have to add mine in here... I don't play him often, but I have a Blood Elf Priest named Elronhubbard...
Coke Superbowl ad says: Get a life, buy soda... nerds
Feb 3rd 2009 4:57PM (Massively)I didn't see anything wrong with this ad...
The great hunter nerf of 2008
Dec 9th 2008 1:44PM (WoW)-marsh
(now playing a druid)