In EVE you are the captain of a giant star ship (yes, even the smallest ships have a small crew). You are giving orders which are then carried out by the crew, hence the point and click interface. I play EVE because I like being the captain.

Black Prophecy gives you the opportunity to be the pilot. If you want dog fights in space rather than naval battles in space then this is most likely for you. They're totally different games and it isn't fair to compare them as though they were trying to achieve the same thing just because they have a similar setting.

I'll be playing both!