> The developers make no attempt to welcome new players to the game

That's false. They're really trying to shape the new player experience to more "user friendly". They've done countless changes over the years. I agree that the new player experience is still not quite what it should be - but saying that the developers are making no attempts to welcome new players is just plain false.

I agree on your blob-warfare thoughts though. At least to the point of where I'd really like to see CCP promote skirmish warfare through game mechanics more than they've done so far (the stealth and Black Ops changes were kinda ok, but I want to see more).

EVE is by no means "ready" and it still has long ways to go - but it's by far the best MMO out there both in terms of developer attention (and how eager they're to overhaul and re-invent the game) and in involvement required - EVE requires attention, concentration and skill - it's not for everyone, nor is it trying to be.