So turbine thinks they are going to take a generation or two of FPS/action lovers and actually think LOTR will do well on the XBOX? or any console for that matter?

This is a laugh and a half. Knowing the devs that probably thought this up it makes sense, to see Turbine make boneheaded moves (or even consider) like this is entertainment indeed.

Of course if they are turning the XBOX version of LOTR into pvp fighting on an epic scale, Lore based on the books, action everywhere, danger lurking at every turn, consequences for actions taken........naw.