In a sad bit of news to start the new year, it would appear that a teenager in Fairfield Township, Ohio, was taken into custody yesterday for falsely claiming that he would commit suicide if a Blizzard support representative did not give in to his request. The young man, who remains nameless due to being underage, was arrested for "inducing panic" which carries a first-degree misdemeanor charge according to the Middletown Journal.
The young man was chatting with a Blizzard rep and made the statement that he was "suicidal and that the game was the only thing that he had to live for." Whether or not this was World of Warcraft or a Battle.net account was not disclosed, but even still, it has raised the question in a few circles if Blizzard was beyond the bounds in bringing the police into this situation - or why the police might arrest someone for it.
Personally, based on my previous experience in technical support for a large multinational Internet company, these types of threats are sadly more commonplace than the average person may realize. When someone's primary method of connecting socially with others is removed - via internet, basic telephony, or networked gaming - you will see a scattered handful who claim that their life is no longer worth living, and then threaten suicide if they aren't helped. Admittedly, the grand majority are falsehoods intended to sway the representative into feeling bad and perhaps caving into the user's unreasonable expectations of service. The problem is that if if the representative doesn't treat every single threat as credible, they open their employer up to liability. Between liability and frequency, most large companies have strict policies on the books to deal with just such situations.
As a case in point at my previously mentioned employer; when we received any admission like that from a customer, we had a series of steps to follow. At the basic level, reps would hit a literal "panic button" twice; the first to screenshot the chat or start a recording which was archived immediately to a secure server; the second activated a flag on the primary control desk where supervisors monitored everything. From there supervisors would either jack in on the call in question to monitor and/or take over if the rep was too flustered, or would supervise the chat from their own screen/walk to the person's terminal and take over if needed. Meanwhile, the acting floor manager would have already pulled up the account information and be looking up the nearby police to send a squad car out and check on the person who had made the threat.
In many cases that I personally dealt with, this resulted in one of two things occurring to the person who made the suicide threat to us. Either the person was found to be a credible threat to their own safety and would be placed under brief protective custody for psychiatric observation, or they were cited and/or arrested on a misdemeanor charge for essentially causing the police to follow up on a false claim and wasting taxpayer dollars. In the first case, the person in trouble was able to get the help they need, and in the second, they were essentially made to pay the tab for their folly.
That said, while more common than you'd realize, these threats are never an easy thing for a representative - or manager - to deal with. You never know if the person is serious, or if they are simply faking it - and who would want to take that chance? In all, I have to applaud the Blizzard rep for following a wise course of action, Blizzard for making sure the policies are in place, and the Fairfield police for ensuring the young man's safety even though his claim turned out to be false. We're also glad to hear that it wasn't a serious threat, and hope that the young man has learned something valuable about making these types of idle threats - even if it is 'just on the Internet.'
[Via GamePolitics]
Reader Comments (27)
Posted: Jan 1st 2009 4:36PM Abriael said
Bringing in the police was definately a good idea, for the kid's own good. Wheter an arrest was warranted or not, I'm not sure, but I would have called the police as well. Wheter the threat is real or not, better to let professionals handle it.
Posted: Jan 1st 2009 5:10PM Graill440 said
This is brought to you by a slice of the demographics in WOW "your community". It is to chuckle.
Posted: Jan 1st 2009 5:21PM ultimateq said
I wonder what he was trying to get.
Posted: Jan 1st 2009 5:50PM TheJackman said
Blizzard support still kinda sucks but its miles ahead of the support of EA (include Warhammer) and at the other side of the earth form Age of Conan.
But a answer of Blizzard support (if not a ingame issue) can take days and before that you get a standard answer email that pretty much does not help you with anything. Also Game Masters late a lot to answer your tickets and worst part is that you have to be online for they can help you even for the more clear simple request!
Yeah MMO support have a long way to go still!!
But a answer of Blizzard support (if not a ingame issue) can take days and before that you get a standard answer email that pretty much does not help you with anything. Also Game Masters late a lot to answer your tickets and worst part is that you have to be online for they can help you even for the more clear simple request!
Yeah MMO support have a long way to go still!!
Posted: Jan 1st 2009 6:42PM (Unverified) said
Hey Hey, Blizzard has the best on-hold music of any place I've ever called, it was a joy to call their customer service.
That being said, on the topic at hand, Blizzard is completely in the right here. Calling the police was the right decision, even if it was to just make sure the kid got the help he needed. This is a sad state of affairs though, this kid needs professional help and (judging by the fact the article says he's underage) needs the assistance of his parents. Get those idiots involved :p
That being said, on the topic at hand, Blizzard is completely in the right here. Calling the police was the right decision, even if it was to just make sure the kid got the help he needed. This is a sad state of affairs though, this kid needs professional help and (judging by the fact the article says he's underage) needs the assistance of his parents. Get those idiots involved :p
Posted: Jan 1st 2009 6:44PM (Unverified) said
I think Blizzard did the right thing here.
Not only to save a life, but they cover themselves as well. IIRC, in some areas, ignoring a suicide attempt or the threat of one is a criminal act. As well as opening themselves up to civil liabilities.
"My son killed himself. he told you he was going to do it, and you did nothing to stop it."
Yeah, huge lawsuit there.
Bliz did right there, all around.
Not only to save a life, but they cover themselves as well. IIRC, in some areas, ignoring a suicide attempt or the threat of one is a criminal act. As well as opening themselves up to civil liabilities.
"My son killed himself. he told you he was going to do it, and you did nothing to stop it."
Yeah, huge lawsuit there.
Bliz did right there, all around.
Posted: Jan 1st 2009 7:21PM (Unverified) said
Although what the kid said was kind of stupid, I hate seeing people getting arrested for saying something
Posted: Jan 1st 2009 8:50PM (Unverified) said
Threatening (or attempting) suicide itself can get you arrested and charged in some jurisdictions.
Reply
Posted: Jan 2nd 2009 1:08AM (Unverified) said
True - but some usages of words are against the law in some places. Words can constitute assault in some jurisdictions (the USA, for example where words and/or bodily posture constitutes assault, but actual physical harm is battery).
You can't yell 'fire' in a theater if there is no fire. Some jurisdictions criminalize certain combinations of words or physical appearance as 'causing public fear'.
Words are words, but sociopolitical rules and laws may give them considerably more significance. It's been that way for at least a couple centuries now.
Reply
You can't yell 'fire' in a theater if there is no fire. Some jurisdictions criminalize certain combinations of words or physical appearance as 'causing public fear'.
Words are words, but sociopolitical rules and laws may give them considerably more significance. It's been that way for at least a couple centuries now.
Posted: Jan 1st 2009 7:56PM (Unverified) said
this a strategy that is used by those who have banned useing glider.
people who glide always ask "how can i get my account back" and a common thing said to them on the glider forums "tell you sucidal and this game is the only thing in your life"
Sorry my english and spelling suck. But yeah 20 bucs says he just lost an account for glideing and got arrested for a false threat...
people who glide always ask "how can i get my account back" and a common thing said to them on the glider forums "tell you sucidal and this game is the only thing in your life"
Sorry my english and spelling suck. But yeah 20 bucs says he just lost an account for glideing and got arrested for a false threat...
Posted: Jan 1st 2009 7:57PM Ripper McGee said
I definitely think Blizzard did the right thing. At minimum, getting the police involved was the quickest way to ensure the teen didn't harm himself. Are the Blizzard reps qualified to triage potential suicide cases? Probably not - turn them over to professionals and let them take care of it. Once he's processed, the police/courts can have somebody evaluate him to see if he's truly a danger to himself, others or if he's just an ignorant little asshat.
Also, there's the issue of liability, as another poster mentioned, although this should always take backseat to safety concerns, IMO.
All-in-all, this was a good move on Blizzard's part. Hopefully the kid truly isn't suicidal, but if he is they probably helped avert a tragedy and the authorities will get the teen the assistance he needs (hopefully).
~Ripper
Also, there's the issue of liability, as another poster mentioned, although this should always take backseat to safety concerns, IMO.
All-in-all, this was a good move on Blizzard's part. Hopefully the kid truly isn't suicidal, but if he is they probably helped avert a tragedy and the authorities will get the teen the assistance he needs (hopefully).
~Ripper
Posted: Jan 2nd 2009 12:28AM fatpanda said
"for falsely claiming that he would commit suicide"
How do they know it is a false claim?
How do they know it is a false claim?
Posted: Jan 2nd 2009 6:21AM Krystalle Voecks said
Per the original article, when the police went to check on him, he said it was "a joke." Thus, false claim.
Reply
Posted: Jan 2nd 2009 1:36AM Graill440 said
The potential for litigation in both the gaming environment and the forum environment is huge. It is simply a matter of time before the first big case turns the MMO world on its ear.
Maybe the loss of some of this kids freedom, and there will be loss, will show him/her/it that consequence exists.
Maybe the loss of some of this kids freedom, and there will be loss, will show him/her/it that consequence exists.
Posted: Jan 2nd 2009 1:58AM (Unverified) said
Some people might say that would be a loss of net neutrality.. =P
Reply
Posted: Jan 2nd 2009 6:43AM Mystal said
Not enough information is provided to know if it was appropriate to contact the police or whether it was appropriate for them to charge him with a criminal count of anything.
If the kid was acting as though he was imminently going to commit suicide, then I'd say calling the cops was the right thing.
I'm not really sure what the grounds are for charging him with a crime, although it's certainly stupid and irresponsible to claim you're suicidal if you're not, just to get your way with a GM.
If the kid was acting as though he was imminently going to commit suicide, then I'd say calling the cops was the right thing.
I'm not really sure what the grounds are for charging him with a crime, although it's certainly stupid and irresponsible to claim you're suicidal if you're not, just to get your way with a GM.
Posted: Jan 2nd 2009 2:26PM Darkdust said
I had a similar experience where I reported a suicidal player to SOE, and they said there was nothing they could do. (!)
I did manage to get in touch with his local police department myself, and he's okay now, but the company could have done so MUCH more quickly than what it took for me to do that.
I did manage to get in touch with his local police department myself, and he's okay now, but the company could have done so MUCH more quickly than what it took for me to do that.









