I have to agree on the PvP front - it is an aspect of games that has grown on me this past year ( partly because it featured prominantly in both the big launches ), but as WAR showcases it tends to come at the expense of everything else.
My hopes remain pinned on Guild Wars 2 delivering a game in which PvP can co-exist peacefully with PvE.

Regarding the other games :

AoC & LotR have been tempting me to return recently, but I KNOW that neither game has addressed the keyboard-slumping autorun tedium that drove me away so I shall have to stay out.
I'd say both games have a reliable future, but I feel only a certain breed ( or generation ? ) of gamer can play them contentedly and that isn't likely to change.

I loathed Shaiya, but well done that team for making it in to the big leagues.

Yay Guild Wars !
I've contributed to that upward growth, though I'll be drifting away again soon enough.