I tried WAR and (in my opinion) the overall game is a mere shadow of what LOTRO is. WAR's graphics, music and sounds are horrible, the PvE is one of the worst in any major MMORPG and crafting is an absolute joke and might as well be non-existent. Yeah the PvP is good, and there are sieges (occasionally, when the scenarios aren't eating up all the players), but when the rest of the game is so lacking, a decent PvP system is not enough to make up for it.

That and the game makes a complete mockery of Warhammer lore, even for a game adaptation. And that's coming from a REAL Warhammer player who has been involved with the hobby for over 15 years.

I'll stick with LOTRO's average PvP thanks and arguably unrivaled PvE, thanks.