The list of them can be counted on the fingers of one hand: Phantasy Star Online
, for the Dreamcast
; Everquest Online Adventures
and Final Fantasy XI
for the Playstation 2
; and Phantasy Star Universe
for both the PS2 and the Xbox 360. And that's it. The only MMO currently thought to be planned for release on both PC and console (though not at launch) is Age of Conan
for the 360. Why is there such a dearth of console MMOs?
Many will say that it's because MMOs are so complex and rich that they cannot be managed with a console controller, and that's partly true -- imagine playing World of Warcraft
with a DualShock
-- but that's more of a design issue. A game meant for consoles, rather than one ported over from the PC, should have such limitations in mind. There's also the closed environment of the console, which is harder to plan patches for, and the still-in-its-infancy online service for the three major brands
. On the bright side, there would be no need to worry about system specs; every player would be getting the same experience. And there could be added value in game achievements
, which is a system that doesn't currently exist for PC MMOs.
Are there more reasons against console MMOs than there are for them? Should developers bother with the consoles at all?