That list seems like the whole point of it was to end up with the controversial line of every North American MMO since WoW being a failure. I don't see any possibility of WoW being topped at the moment, not because it's such a "good game", but because it just has so many people.

I don't really like WoW and I know I'm probably not the only one who thinks this, but WoW feels too much like a job to me. Getting everything perfect so you can be accepted into a worthy guild, participate in end game content, and not have a character that hits 100 less than what you could be hitting for your race, class, and level.