If you had any doubt at all that EVE Online is the thinking man's MMO, you won't any longer. CCP has released a 20 page paper in PDF format describing the new Council of Stellar Management, and you know you're in for something good when the paper starts off with the social theories of the Greek philosopher Aristotle.
This is one of the times when it's particularly clear just how bizarre and interesting it is to be writing about virtual societies. This is the stuff of cyberpunk novels and Star Trek: The Next Generation episodes. CCP has produced something like the first draft of a constitution (with notes) for a representative government, with references to John Locke's social contract theory and everything else you'd expect from such a document. No doubt EVE's scheming political players are already looking through the document for loopholes and potential abuses. It may not be long before EVE players are having debates about campaign finance reform and separation of powers.
Richard Bartle doesn't think this will work. Whether it works or not, though, it'll be damned interesting. At the very least, it will be more fodder for discussion relating to Hardcore Casual's EVE Challenge.
[Via MMORPG]
Reader Comments (2)
Posted: Nov 16th 2007 6:07PM (Unverified) said
The first thought that leaps to mind is: "The mice are voting to bell the cat." The meaning of that phrase is: You can have all the democracy you want, but without power to affect the world, it's totally useless.
The thing is, the EVE council is going to jump through dozens of hoops and go through tremendous strain just to come to a consensus on RECOMMENDATIONS which CCP will then read politely, nod, gravely thank them for, and then quietly drop into the wastepaper basket as soon as they've walked out the door.
The thing is, the EVE council is going to jump through dozens of hoops and go through tremendous strain just to come to a consensus on RECOMMENDATIONS which CCP will then read politely, nod, gravely thank them for, and then quietly drop into the wastepaper basket as soon as they've walked out the door.
Posted: Nov 19th 2007 12:03PM (Unverified) said
It's a misconception that the CSM is means for the players to get their say in the development of EVE and how the game design, game play and overall game is run.
From the various interviews I've read, what CCP is trying to do, is give a chance for all members of the EVE community to have their voices heard. The forums allow some players to do this, but only for a small percentage of the player base.
With the CSM, all players will have a way to be heard. It will then by the responsibilty of the CSM members to review the requests and concerns put forth to them and come-up with their recommendation to CCP. It's a fair way for the community to be heard, and an easier way for CCP to manage these concerns.
In this way, the CSM will act as an ombudsman does; it'll be able to recommend to CCP, what it believes is best for the EVE community.
From the various interviews I've read, what CCP is trying to do, is give a chance for all members of the EVE community to have their voices heard. The forums allow some players to do this, but only for a small percentage of the player base.
With the CSM, all players will have a way to be heard. It will then by the responsibilty of the CSM members to review the requests and concerns put forth to them and come-up with their recommendation to CCP. It's a fair way for the community to be heard, and an easier way for CCP to manage these concerns.
In this way, the CSM will act as an ombudsman does; it'll be able to recommend to CCP, what it believes is best for the EVE community.







